For five months, William Alderson, a founding trustee of H:MC21, worked on a thorough critique of Simon Singh and Edzard Ernst’s book Trick or Treatment? Alternative medicine on trial (London: Bantam, 2008)
The critique analyses each chapter in turn and details no less than nineteen major faults in Ernst and Singh’s approach.
It concludes that:
"Trick or Treatment? has no validity as a scientific examination of alternative medicine”.
The text can be downloaded free by clicking on the buttons below.